What’s the Difference Between Pleading Guilty and No Contest?

A courtroom is a daunting place, especially when you face criminal charges. There are rules, procedures, and crucial decisions waiting at every turn. One of the most critical choices you’ll face is how to plead. You might have heard terms like “guilty” and “no contest,” but what do they truly mean? And how do they affect your case?

At the Law Office of Case J. Darwin, we believe an informed defendant is a more empowered one. As a former prosecutor in Houston, Case J. Darwin has seen firsthand the intricacies of the Texas justice system and knows how crucial your choice of plea can be in criminal cases.

Your Three Plea Choices in a Criminal Case

After the police arrest you, your first court appearance is at your arraignment. This appearance is when defendants typically choose how they wish to plead in their case. You have three choices when it’s time to plead in a criminal case:

Not Guilty

When you plead “not guilty,” you’re essentially telling the court that you are innocent of the charges against you. This plea starts the process where your attorney and the prosecutor will prepare for trial. The court will later determine whether there’s enough evidence to prove your guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If not, you could be acquitted, which means you won’t be convicted of the crime.


Pleading “guilty” is a clear admission that you committed the crime in question. There won’t be a trial to determine your innocence or guilt, as you’ve already admitted to the crime. The next steps involve the judge determining an appropriate sentence based on the specifics of your case and any plea deal you may reach with the prosecutor.

No Contest

This plea, also called “nolo contendere,” means you’re not admitting guilt, but you’re also not contesting the charges. It’s a way to say, “I’m not admitting I did it, but I won’t fight the charges.” One key thing to remember here is that a “no contest” plea often has the same legal result as a “guilty” plea as far as sentencing goes.

It’s essential to understand these plea choices fully, as your decision will significantly impact the direction of your case. Seeking advice from a knowledgeable attorney is invaluable during this stage to ensure you make the best choice for your unique situation.

The Difference Between Pleading Guilty and No Content

At first glance, pleading guilty and no contest seem remarkably similar. Both lead to a conviction and in many cases, the outcome regarding penalties is the same. However, the nuances between these two pleas become particularly evident when considering potential civil proceedings related to a criminal case.

When you plead guilty, you openly admit fault or responsibility for the crime charged. This admission of guilt can be used as evidence against you in any related civil lawsuit. For instance, if prosecutors charged you with DUI and you later faced a civil lawsuit from an injured driver, your guilty plea in the criminal case could be used as evidence in the civil case. The admission may strengthen the other party’s case against you in a lawsuit.

On the other hand, a no-contest plea doesn’t involve an admission of guilt. Instead, you’re saying you won’t contest the charges against you. This distinction is crucial in potential civil proceedings. Since you haven’t admitted guilt, your no-contest plea generally can’t be used as evidence against you in a related civil case.

One final thing to note: A no-contest plea is not always an option in criminal cases. If you are charged with a felony or in some cases where there may be a personal injury or property damage lawsuit, a no-contest plea may not be allowed. Additionally, prosecutors sometimes insist on a guilty plea as part of a plea bargain, meaning you must either admit your guilt or take your chances at trial. An experienced and knowledgeable attorney can negotiate with the prosecution on your behalf for a plea deal that allows you to plead no contest instead of guilty.

What’s the Right Choice?

Whether you should plead guilty or no contest depends on the specific circumstances of your case. If you might face a civil case related to your alleged crime, a no-contest plea can help you avoid giving the plaintiff a powerful piece of evidence. On the other hand, a guilty plea might get you a better deal from the prosecution, but it’s essential to weigh the potential for a civil lawsuit. The bottom line: Always talk with your defense attorney before deciding how to plead.

How Our San Marcos Defense Attorney Can Help You

Navigating the maze of legal decisions following a criminal charge is often overwhelming. In these critical moments, having a knowledgeable defense attorney by your side can make a world of difference. Here’s how San Marcos defense attorney Case J. Darwin can help:

  • Understanding the Charges: Before making an informed decision on how to plead, you must thoroughly understand the charges against you. An experienced defense attorney will break down the legal jargon, ensuring you understand the allegations’ full scope and potential consequences.
  • Evaluating Evidence: A cornerstone of any defense is understanding the evidence the prosecution has against you. Case J. Darwin can scrutinize the evidence, assess its strength or weakness, and advise you on how it could influence the outcome should your case go to trial.
  • Negotiating Plea Bargains: Sometimes, the best option is to negotiate with the prosecutor for a more lenient sentence or reduced charges in exchange for a particular plea. An adept defense attorney can often broker better plea deals, given their understanding of the system and rapport with local prosecutors.
  • Protection of Your Rights: One of a defense attorney’s key jobs is to uphold your rights throughout the legal process. They can challenge any unlawfully obtained evidence, ensure police and prosecutors treat you fairly, and carry out the necessary court procedures.
  • Guidance on Civil Implications: As discussed earlier, certain pleas can influence related civil proceedings. An informed attorney can guide you on these potential repercussions, ensuring you consider the broader picture.

Your choice of plea in a criminal case is vital, and it’s essential to make the right choice. Attorney Case J. Darwin can provide the guidance and support you need. Call (512) 738-6146 now or complete our online contact form for a free consultation.


Image by Wesley Tingey Licensed via Unsplash

top criminal attorneys in san antonio
San Marcos Criminal Defense Lawyers Association
Avvo logo
Expertise Award for Best Criminal Defense Lawyers in San Antonio 2020